|
Law
Civil courts in UK: does it need a reform?
...This paper is going to look into the structure of the
civil court of the UK.
There are over four hundred county courts in England and
Wales and they are staffed by Circuit Judges and District
Judges. The Circuit Judge is appointed by the crown from
advice of the Lord Chancellor. The Circuit Judge would
usually sit alone although there is the possibility of trial
by a jury of eight persons in some cases. A District Judge
may also be appointed as a temporary measure to clear up any
business in the County Court. The county court will hear
cases for claims up to Ј25,000 or any personal injury case
which is less than Ј50,000, unless the cases are extremely
complex (Slapper and Kelly, 2003). The County Court is bound
by the decisions of all the higher courts and decisions made
by the County Court does not bind any other court. The
decision made by the County Court may be appealed, which are
usually made to the High Court. As the County Court is very
formal, inflexible, costly, time consuming and some issues
may be too technical for judges to resolve Alternative
Dispute Resolution may be used. Negotiation is favoured by
the court as hopefully the matter can be resolved before the
court hearing. There may be a tribunal which operates
alongside the courts and are used as an alternative to the
courts, often because they are more appropriate. A tribunal
usually comprises of three people, one legally qualified
chairperson and two experts with the knowledge of the
individual cases...
read more
Trial Jury: guarantee against injustice?
...A defendant is a person accused of a wrong doing of a
criminal or civil action. Moreover the word injustice has
been an issue for many centuries. As injustice is a form of
unfair treatment or action against any one person, (Collins
English Dictionary). Injustice can be said to be a
“violation of another’s right or of what is right; lack of
justice… A specific unjust act; a wrong”
The word ‘trial’ originates from the Anglo-French, from ‘trier’,
‘to try’. (www.gurunet.com). The English Dictionary defines
trial as the, “investigation of a case before a judge” The
more serious criminal cases are tried on the basis of a
document called the indictment - the defendant is indicted
on criminal charges specified in the indictment by the
prosecutor. In most cases, the prosecution is on behalf of
the Crown (the State) and is handled by an official agency
called the Crown Prosecution Service, which takes the case
over from the police who have already investigated most of
the evidence. The first stage will be to decide whether
there is a case to answer - what is called a prima facie
case. This process, called committal, will be dealt with by
a magistrate on the basis of evidence disclosed in papers
provided by the prosecutor. If the case proceeds, it is
heard in the Crown Court (there is only one Crown Court but
it has about 70 centres around the jurisdiction). The trial
is before a judge and jury. The judge presides over the
trial process by attempting to ensure clarity and fairness.
The judge must also consider and decide on legal issues
(such as whether a piece of evidence is admissible - should
be put before the jury) and also instruct the jury as to the
correct view of the law relevant to the case...
read more
Law from Malaysian Perspective
...In a society with certain structure it is definite that
different individuals will have different opinions which
have to be coordinated by law. Laws is a type of glue stick
that holds society together, so that they can live
peacefully. For example, law of criminal helps to safeguard
the personal property and lives. Law of contract helps to
ensure people keep on their promises
Law protects basic individual rights and freedom such as
liberty, equality and freedom of speech. It prevents
individuals in powerful position from taking an unfair
advantage of other people.
Law ensures a safe and peaceful society, in which individual
rights are preserved. Certain governments have cruel laws,
where police and armies arrests and punishes people without
a trial in the court.
Law applies to every persons, public authorities,
governmental departments, private bodies, profit making
organizations as well as non-governmental organizations.
In Malaysia, the legislative body which is made up of Lower
House and the Upper house, both which consists of
representatives of people, makes law. The executive body
which is headed by YDPA, who is assisted by Prime Minister,
enforces the law, so that everyone will follow. The
judiciary body judges law. These three bodies form the
Malaysian government. The law, however, is an independent
entity by itself although it is made, enforced and judged by
the government...
read more
Man’s concept of morality and lawyer’s outlook on it
...In elucidating whether the lawyer’s litigious role and
notion of professional responsibility initiate divergence
from common perceptions of morality an essential starting
point is to briefly explicate some form of understanding in
relation to the moral values the lawyer’s role ostensibly
subverts. In actual fact providing a definitive answer which
encapsulates the various perspectives espoused in relation
to the notion of common morality is a somewhat unfeasible
task as the concept remains elusive. Nevertheless one
feature has remained dogmatically constant throughout the
various interpretations advocated and that is the importance
of the moral sense. One need only look at ancient mythology
and Zeus’s solution to the inexorable decline of the human
race, the gift of a moral sense, to gain a mesmerising
insight into the inherent importance of morality. Although
historically religious ideology provided much of the
framework in relation to the assessment of moral standards
it is argued that in a modern pluralistic society biblical
authority no longer determines the formulation of ethical
principles. Thus moral philosophy has made a number of
attempts to provide a definitive answer in relation to what
the concept of morality actually embraces and it has been
conveyed that moral duty “is the action which will cause
more good to exist in the universe than any other possible
alternative...
read more
Social problems: what is law’s role in their solutions?
...Amitai Etzioni distinguishes four methods of assessing
social problems. In the first "Consensus and Structural
Function Approach" he defines a social problem as "...what
people think they are.". Thus the law takes no part in
defining social problems, this is the role of society, the
law only attempts to remedy them. His second preposition is
the "Conflict or Alienation Approach" that traces its roots
in Marxist theory. Here the failings of a Capitalist Society
create sub-sections of underclass citizens that are affected
with social problems. Again the law does nothing to define
the problem but the "Conflict" theory suggests its
resolution of social problems is based on a new system of
governing. It can therefore be said that this theory clearly
sees the resolutions of social problems in a structured
state that, by definition, must require a legal system and
suggests all social problems are cured by an adherence to
the law, or nearly all. His third model is "Symbolic
Interactionism and Ethnomethodology" in which individuals
through social interaction define social problems, for
example if all my friends are criminals then I do not find
it a social problem but if all my friends are not then I
find crime a problem. It does not however define how to
solve the problem but suggests that education is the key to
transforming the definition of social problems...
read more
PLACE YOUR ORDER HERE
|